Showing posts with label Rupert Wingfield-Hayes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rupert Wingfield-Hayes. Show all posts

Monday, 11 April 2016

Historian wins ruling against BBC


Here's something you may have missed (as I did, until now)...


The “sanitised narrative” of Hiroshima’s atomic bombing, bbc.co.uk: Finding by the Editorial Complaints Unit
Complaint
According to this online article, the rationale that the use of the A-bombs was intended to shorten the war and avoid an indefinite number of casualties “was constructed after the war, by America’s leaders, to justify what they had done”.  The historian Antony Beevor complained that this stated as fact a view which conflicted with contemporaneous evidence.
Outcome
There are contemporaneous sources which make clear that extremely high estimates of casualties in the event of an invasion of Japan played a major part in US thinking. The ECU concluded that what the article stated as a fact was strongly contested, on the basis of credible evidence. Upheld
Further action
The matter was discussed in detail with the author of the article (the BBC’s Tokyo Correspondent), who revised it in the light of the finding. The headline, which was not the responsibility of the author, was also changed.
The article in question was by Rupert Wingfield-Hayes, and blogs like this (including this very blog) criticised it strongly at the time. 

Would the BBC have 'fessed up though if it hadn't been someone as prestigious as Antony Beevor complaining?

Sunday, 9 August 2015

The 'sanitised narrative' of Rupert Wingfield-Hayes


I very much agree with Alan at Biased BBC about Rupert Wingfield-Hayes's news report on the dropping of the atomic bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, The 'sanitised narrative' of Hiroshima's atomic bombing. 

Alan describes it as "possibly some of the worst and most sanctimonious, malevolent of BBC reporting you’ll ever see", and as "hand-wringing" driven by the BBC's "hatred of what it sees as the European/US, white dominance of history, its kneejerk cultural cringe and guilt-ridden fawning towards other races and cultures by its white reporters and a gleeful free for all from its ethnic reporters who take a great deal of pleasure in attacking the West and its values whether they have lived here all their lives or not like a school child being rude to their teacher".

With barely a mention of the years of relentless barbarity practised on the peoples of East Asia and allied prisoners of war by the Japanese imperial army, RW-H waxes morally indignant about the wickedness of the U.S.'s use of nuclear weapons. 

The piece is so obviously one-sided, opinionated and tendentious that the BBC headline writer must have decided it was safer to put "sanitised narrative" in inverted commas, because that phrase isn't in inverted commas in the report itself. They are RW-H's own words:


Given his own lack of attention to the context of Japan's war-time atrocities in this piece, maybe it's Rupert Wingfield-Hayes whose narrative better deserves the epithet "sanitised".