I came across an unusual blog post in the Times of Israel. It is unusual for a couple of reasons. Firstly because it did what it said on the tin, which is to debunk 25 of the most ubiquitous - what shall we call them? I suggest ‘smears’. Yes, they are genuine smears, against Israel. if I have to spell it out, I’m using the term in its strictest sense, (damage the reputation of (someone) by false accusations; slander) and not as a trumped-up smokescreen, as in the tactic infamously used by the antisemites in the Labour Party to mask the truth.
The second reason the blog post is unusual is that it was written by someone of “Arab origin”. in other words, it was written As-an-Arab.
If the exact same piece had been penned by a Jew, it might well have been passed off with a Mandy Rice-Davies (they would, wouldn’t they) type of shrug, rather than a Jeremy Corbyn (don’t know/don’t care) type of shrug.
You’ll be familiar with Richard Ingrams's infamous boast, which is that he looks first at the author of any letter concerning Israel - and if the name looks “Jewish’ he bins it; by a parallel token, if a supporter or defender of Israel happens to be NotaJew, like, say, John Mann MP, Denis MacEoin, Douglas Murray or Rod Liddle, the words carry extra weight and are more likely to be taken seriously. One might also speculate that the antisemites find them the most infuriating.
Here is what Mr. Maroun says about the “AsaJew” party members that the Labour party flaunts to disguise its antisemitism. (Extracted from myth number 16.)
“Some naïve Jews feel guilty over accusations that Zionism is a modern form of Nazism but the number of Jews who buy the dishonest anti-Zionist rhetoric is very small and very marginal. They are a convenient tool in the hands of Israel’s enemies, so they are quoted often and their importance is magnified well beyond their numbers.”
Did you realise that it is illegal in Lebanon to communicate “in any fashion” with an Israeli?
If Fred Maroun only represents a tiny fraction of the world’s Arabs and Leftists, he still earns his brownie points by dint of his non-Jewish identity.
I would very much like to reproduce the piece in full, as I think it’s an invaluable resource for anyone who suddenly needs to refute any of those widely believed myths neatly and succinctly. However, I don’t want to abuse bloggers’ etiquette and steal the entire content without asking permission. So I’ll compromise, and list the 25 headings here, and post an edited and abridged (by me) version over the fold. I think it has relevance for the BBC, as many of these myths crop up (in fact or innuendo) within much of the BBC's reporting of matters concerning Israel.
The original provides links, and not only to pro-Israel sources. Do go to the article itself to get the full picture, because I can’t guarantee that my editing has done justice to the original.
1. “Israel can end the conflict by withdrawing from the “West Bank””
2. “Israel keeps stealing Palestinian land”
3. “Gaza is an open-air prison / under siege”
4. “Israel is an apartheid/racist state”
5. “The “West Bank” is an even worse apartheid”
6. “Jewish settlements in the “West Bank” are illegal”
7. “It is the Israel-Palestinian conflict”
8. “Trump caused Arabs to riot in Jerusalem”
9. “Israel threatens Lebanon”
10. “Israel is run by a right-wing government that is no better than Hamas
11. “Israel commits genocide against Palestinians”
12. “If some Palestinians behave badly, it is out of desperation”
13. “Israel created the Palestinian refugee crisis”
14. “The conflict is a dispute over land”
15. “Zionists are the new Nazis”
16. “Even Jews think that Israel is a terrorist state”
17. “Israel targets civilians and children”
18. “Israel is an imperialist project”
19. “Israeli Jews are European”
20. “Jews have no right to have their own state”
21. “Europe supported Zionism because of guilt over the Holocaust”
22. “Israel’s support for LGBT rights is a cover for its crimes”
23. “The BDS movement is a reasonable response to Israel”
24. “Hatred of Israel is okay because anti-Zionism is not antisemitism”
25. “Israel is the cause of conflicts in the Middle East”
1. “Israel can end the conflict by withdrawing from the “West Bank””
I would welcome the creation of a Palestinian state, but the possibility is unrealistic under current conditions. Israel’s withdrawal from Gaza in 2005 shows what happens when Israel withdraws unconditionally. Many thousands of rockets have been fired from Gaza into Israel and many tunnels were built to try to infiltrate Israel.
Israel cannot afford to make the same mistake in Judea & Samaria (the correct name for the “West Bank”) which is much closer to Israel’s large cities than Gaza.
it is virtually certain that the newly evacuated land would be controlled by terrorists dangerously hostile to Israel.
2. “Israel keeps stealing Palestinian land”
Israel’s victories in defensive wars do not constitute stealing land. The land of Israel that is within the armistice lines resulting from the 1948 war (and usually referred to as the Green Lines) was legitimately acquired by Israel in a war of self-defence. Judea & Samaria and Gaza were also legitimately acquired by Israel in another war of self-defence in 1967 when several Arab armies congregated around Israel with the objective of destroying it. Israel later gave back the vast majority of that land in a peace agreement with Egypt, it voluntarily relinquished Gaza, and it voluntarily agreed to allow the Palestinian Authority to administer a large part of Judea & Samaria, referred to as areas A and B. What disturbs me as an Arab is that Arabs have at every turn made the wrong decisions, leaving them with less land, and even now that the Palestinians have had a chance to show their administrative capability in Gaza and parts of Judea & Samaria, they transformed Gaza into a terrorist base and they chose to fund terrorism in Judea & Samaria.
3. “Gaza is an open-air prison / under siege”
Israel voluntarily left Gaza in 2005 and only imposed a blockade on Gaza when “Hamas violently took over power from Fatah in 2007” two years after Israel’s withdrawal. The blockade was imposed by Israel and Egypt only after the Hamas authority in Gaza started attacking Israel. The purpose of the blockade is to stop Hamas and other terrorist groups from obtaining weapons with which to attack Israel.
The definition of a ‘seige’ does not apply to Israel’s blockade on Gaza. Israel provides for the regular transfer of non-military goods into Gaza. Every day, “an average of 800 trucks enter the Gaza Strip carrying food, medical equipment, fuel, building materials, agricultural inputs, textile products and more”.
In 2005, the Palestinians of Gaza had a choice. They could have used their newly acquired freedom to build a strong economy in that coastal and fertile land, or they could have used that freedom to fight Israel. They chose the latter.
4. “Israel is an apartheid/racist state”
All ethnicities, including Arabs, are treated equally in Israel. Freedom of religion is also guaranteed and strictly enforced, and so is the protection of holy sites of all religions. The only preference given to Jews is that Jews have an unlimited right of return to Israel, under the Law of Return. Any of many Muslim and Christian countries, some of which are very rich, could provide such a law for Muslims or Christians if they so wished, but none of them do.
Israel also guarantees freedom of assembly, movement, and voting to all citizens, which include Arabs. There are a dozen Arabs in the Knesset (Parliament) and an Arab judge of the Supreme Court. Further, Arabs are very well represented in Israeli universities, both among students and staff. As a left-wing Arab who knows the level of bigotry and racism that exists in the Arab world, Israel is a breath of fresh air. I want the same for us!
5. “The “West Bank” is an even worse apartheid”
Judea & Samaria is indeed an apartheid system, but to the disadvantage of Jews, not of Arabs. Arabs can live and travel anywhere in Judea & Samaria, although Arabs who do not hold Israeli citizenship cannot live in the 1% of Judea & Samaria that consists of Jewish communities, and they must have a security permit to visit. Jews, on the other hand, can only live in that 1% and cannot even travel to large portions that are controlled by the Palestinian Authority (PA). Overall, Arabs have far more rights and far fewer restrictions in Judea & Samaria than do Jews. The ban on Jews in PA-controlled areas reflects the Arab world’s attitude towards Jews since Arabs countries have expelled practically all Jews they once had.
As a left-wing Arab, I think that the Arab inability to accept Jews among them is shameful and counter-productive. Religious and ethnic diversity is an asset, not a weakness.
6. “Jewish settlements in the “West Bank” are illegal”
There are reasonable legal opinions on both sides of the question of whether Jewish settlements in Judea & Samaria are illegal, but there is no dispute on one fact, which is that the Arab deportations of Jews from Judea & Samaria during the war of 1948 were illegal and even criminal. The return of Jews to that land is only fair, and there is no reasonable rationale as to why Jews in Judea & Samaria should not be welcome within a Palestinian state if such a state was formed on that land unless one is to accept that Arabs are incapable of living peacefully with Jews.
As an Arab, I know that many if not most individual Arabs are capable of living peacefully with Jews. If Arab regimes are not capable of it, Jews should not be the ones punished by being banned from settling on land that has a Jewish history that is far deeper than any Palestinian history.
7. “It is the Israel-Palestinian conflict”
When Israel gained independence in 1948, those who referred to themselves as Palestinians were the Jews. Zuheir Moshan, PLO Commander from 1971 to 1979 said, “The Palestinian people does not exist. The creation of a Palestine state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel for our Arab unity.” The conflict is not between Israeli and Palestinian, but between the entire Arab world and the Jews.
Arabs had a choice from the start, and they still do: accept the Jewish state and benefit from Israel’s contributions to the Middle East, or fight the Jews tooth and nail. They chose the latter. The Arab world is very slowly moving towards acceptance of Israel, but we are not there yet, and the support that the Arab world still provides to the Palestinian extremists in continuing the conflict is an important obstacle to its resolution.
8. “Trump caused Arabs to riot in Jerusalem”
The attacks on Jews in Jerusalem date back to long ago. In the war of 1948, the Jewish residents were forcibly exiled from the portion of Jerusalem that the Arabs occupied, and Jewish religious sites were destroyed and desecrated. After the war of 1967 during which Israel took back all of Jerusalem and annexed it, no Arabs were deported and Israel granted Jordan guardianship of “Haram al-Sharif”, the Islamic holy site on the Temple Mount.
Haj Amin al-Husseini, the grand mufti of Jerusalem at the time, made the claim in 1929 that the Jews wished to destroy Al Aqsa Mosque, causing a massacre of Jews by Arabs. Israel clearly has the military capability today to destroy Al Aqsa Mosque if it wished to do so, but it does not, yet that lie is still repeated, and it is the cause of Muslim riots.
Trump’s declaration on Jerusalem was simply the recognition of a fact. Trump, in my opinion, did not go far enough, and should have declared Jerusalem indivisible and fully part of Israel; Arabs like myself who are truly concerned about preserving all religious sites and all religious rights in Jerusalem are quite pleased with Israel’s administration of Jerusalem.
9. “Israel threatens Lebanon”
I want what is best for Lebanon; peace with Israel. Israel has absolutely no interest and has never had any interest in occupying or threatening any part of Lebanon. Its only interest has been to prevent terrorist attacks from Lebanese soil, first by the PLO then by Hezbollah. It is the Hezbollah-controlled Lebanon that insists on maintaining a state of war with Israel. That does not benefit the Lebanese people but gives Hezbollah an excuse to remain armed and to maintain an illegitimate control over Lebanese institutions.
10. “Israel is run by a right-wing government that is no better than Hamas”
The analogies between Hamas and Israel’s Likud party are false. Israel has accepted and initiated, partition plans that would have seen the creation of a Palestinian state next to Israel. Many Israelis today typically vote for right-wing parties due to their doubt that the PA will ever agree to a reasonable peace plan. The current Israeli government is a coalition of mostly right-wing parties and has consistently requested to negotiate peace with the Palestinians but the PA has consistently refused. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu even released hardened terrorists in an attempt to kick-start peace talks, which is certainly a proof of his commitment to peace. Before him, Menachem Begin negotiated peace with Egypt, and Ariel Sharon withdrew unconditionally from Gaza; both were considered hawkish right-wing Prime Ministers.
Palestinian authorities, on the other hand, continue to encourage terrorism and to refuse to pursue peace. That is the real obstacle to peace.
Although the Netanyahu government is right-wing by Israeli and Western standards, it is far to the left of any Arab regime.
11. “Israel commits genocide against Palestinians”
This is the most absurd of all the myths. The Ma’an News Agency, a Palestinian news agency, reported in 2011 that since Israel’s independence in 1948, the Palestinian population had grown 8-fold; this is an average of 3.4% yearly growth rate, far higher than the average world population growth, which varied between 0.8% and 2.1% during the same period. This must be the most ineffective genocide in history. Israel’s military is powerful and extremely effective. Israel has clearly never shown any inclination towards genocide.
But even though the accusation is easy to refute, enemies of Israel repeat it anyway because they know that it deeply pains many Jews who still carry the scars of the Holocaust and who have pledged that “Never Again.” As a left-wing Arab, I am deeply embarrassed that my fellow leftists and Arabs sink so low as to make this highly callous and calculated accusation.
12. “If some Palestinians behave badly, it is out of desperation”
There are hundreds of groups worldwide that are actively seeking independence and typically under far worse conditions and with far fewer options than the Palestinians. Those include Armenians in Azerbaijan; the Jumma people and the Bengali Hindus in Bangladesh; a dozen different groups in Burma; Mongolians, Tibetans, and Uyghurs in China; Abkhazians, Ossetians, and Armenians in Georgia; seven groups in India; and many others over all continents. If any of these groups were offered a state, as Palestinians were offered several times already, it is highly unlikely that it would have turned it down, yet terrorism is typically a very rare occurrence among those groups.
Palestinians are mistreated by Arab regimes, and they face apartheid in Arab states (which, as an Arab, I am ashamed of), and some may be understandably frustrated, but they receive extensive support and funding. Compared to practically any other group that seeks statehood, Palestinians have far less reason to feel desperate, yet they are extensively involved in terrorism. Hamas even admits to targeting civilians while predictably claiming to have excuses to do it.
Palestinians have had many choices to make over the last 70 years, and they have far too often made the wrong ones. Palestinian terrorism continues in fact because due to international aid, they can afford, to hold off on accepting any solution until they get what their terrorist organizations have always openly demanded – the destruction of the Jewish state.
13. “Israel created the Palestinian refugee crisis”
There would not be a single Palestinian refugee today if the Arab world had accepted the 1947 UN partition plan, as Israel did. Both Jewish and Arab refugees resulted from a war that the Arab world imposed on Israel. While the Israel-Arab conflict generated 711,000 Palestinian refugees, it also generated 856,000 Jewish refugees from Arab lands. The Jewish refugees were absorbed by other countries, mostly Israel, but the Arab world refused to absorb Arab refugees, keeping them in camps with limited rights. As an Arab, I am angry that the Arab world uses Palestinian refugees as pawns against Israel.
In 1952, the UNRWA (United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees) director, Sir Alexander Galloway, put it bluntly when he said, “It is perfectly clear that the Arab nations do not want to solve the Arab refugee problem. They want to keep it as an open sore, as an affront against the United Nations and as a weapon against Israel. Arab leaders don’t give a damn whether the refugees live or die.” The Arab world, not Israel, created the Palestinian refugee crisis and ensured that 70 years later, it is still not resolved.
14. “The conflict is a dispute over land”
Israel is less than 0.2% of the size of the Arab world, not to mention Iran. The conflict has never been about land but about Arabs rejecting Jewish self-determination in the Middle East. After the 1967 war during which Israel took a significant amount of land in a war of self-defence, Israel sought to return land for peace, but the Arab world’s response was three Nos: no peace, no negotiations, and no recognition of Israel.
Why are my fellow Arabs so afraid of one tiny Jewish neighbour?
15. “Zionists are the new Nazis”
This accusation is easy to refute. Nazism was marked by two significant aspects: Military expansionism and a form of racism/bigotry that led to the coldblooded murder of ten million non-combatants, including six million Jews. Israel’s wars were always undertaken in self-defence to stop military and terrorist attacks. Any land acquired by Israel was legitimate under the laws of war, and Israel has already returned the vast majority of that land (most notably the Sinai which alone is more than double the size of Israel) in exchange for peace, and it would have returned even more if Syria and the Palestinians had agreed to peace agreements that Israel was willing to accept.
In addition to the Jews not being “the new Nazis”, what disturbs me most as an Arab is that it is, in fact, the Palestinians who in the past had ties to Nazis and who today behave in ways that are similar to the Nazis.
16. “Even Jews think that Israel is a terrorist state”
Some naïve Jews feel guilty over accusations that Zionism is a modern form of Nazism but the number of Jews who buy the dishonest anti-Zionist rhetoric is very small and very marginal. They are a convenient tool in the hands of Israel’s enemies, so they are quoted often and their importance is magnified well beyond their numbers. Their existence, in fact, demonstrates the democratic nature of Israel and the Jewish community. The Arab world, on the other hand, tolerates no dissent from imposed opinions.
In Lebanon, my country of origin, it is even illegal to communicate in any fashion with an Israeli. Because of my support for peace with Israel, I can never visit my own native country.
17. “Israel targets civilians and children”
When civilians or children are unintentionally killed in IDF operations, it is front-page news all over the world, resulting in very negative publicity for Israel. Israel gains nothing from killing Palestinian civilians, but Palestinian terrorist organizations gain world sympathy, which is why they often place civilians in dangerous positions during conflicts with Israel. The Palestinian authorities teach hatred towards Jews and Israel, thus ensuring that the conflict can never be resolved peacefully.
The targeting of Israeli civilians by Palestinian terrorists is largely ignored by mainstream media, but even more surprisingly, while some courageous Arabs such as Khaled Abu Toameh and Bassam Tawil often raise the issue of Palestinian terrorists’ violence and abuse against Palestinian civilians and children, the mainstream media ignores that too.
18. “Israel is an imperialist project”
Jews are aboriginal people to the land of Israel. They are the ones who have been victims of imperialism. They suffered many massacres, including two sieges of Jerusalem by the Romans (63 BC and 37 BC), massacres by the Romans (4-6 BC, 36, 66, 115-117, and 132-136), the siege of Jerusalem by the Persians (614), the massacres by Christians (605 and 1099), the Hebron and Safed attacks by Kurds and Muslims (1517), the destructions of Tiberias and Safed by the Druze and Arabs (1660), the siege of Jaffa by the French army (1799), the Hebron massacre by the Egyptians (1834), the attack on Safed by the Druze and Arabs (1838), The Arab attacks on Petach Tikva (1886), the riots in Jerusalem instigated the Grand Mufti (1920), the Jaffa Arab riots (1921), the Arab Riots in Safed (1929), the Hebron massacre instigated by the Grand Mufti (1929), the Great Arab Revolt (1936-1939), and the Tiberius massacre by Arabs (1938). As a result of these massacres, many Jews were forced to flee.
As an Arab, it is my duty to recognize the Arab responsibility in several of these massacres, and I wish that other Arabs did the same rather than fabricate claims of imperialism. The Zionist project of allowing Jews to return to their land is in fact the opposite of an imperialist project. It is an attempt to reverse in a small way centuries of imperialist attacks on the Jews. Of course, the dead and their potential descendants can never be brought back, but Israel allows the descendants of the Jews who survived to return to the land that they should never have been forced to leave.
19. “Israeli Jews are European”
Some of Israel’s Jews have European lineage, but it would be false to say that all or even most of them do. There are a little over 6 million Jews in Israel today. Many of them are Jewish refugees from Arab lands or their descendants. We know that there were originally 711,000 Palestinian refugees, and the UNRWA claimed in January 2015 that living refugees and their descendants total 5 million people. It is logical then to assume that from the original 856,000 Jewish refugees from Arab lands, we now have at least 5 million Jewish refugees and descendants. By that estimate, Arab Jews make up the majority of the six million Israeli Jews. There are also many Israeli Jews who are descendants of Jews who never left the land of Israel. Even among the Israeli Jews whose ancestors lived in Europe, the only ones who would have no Middle Eastern blood are those who converted to Judaism, but conversion to Judaism is relatively rare since Jews, unlike Muslims and Christians, do not proselytize.
Israel’s official numbers from 2015 show the following counts based on paternal country of origin for a total of 6.3 million Israeli Jews:
Israel: 2.8 million.
Africa: 0.9 million.
Russia: 0.9 million.
Asia: 0.7 million.
Europe: 0.7 million.
America and Oceania: 0.3 million.
20. “Jews have no right to have their own state”
The Jewish state has at least as much the right to exist as any other state on earth. Jews have a continuous history of over 3000 years in the land of Israel, despite being repeatedly massacred and forced to flee. If the Jewish people is not allowed to be independent on that land then no people should be allowed to be independent anywhere. The reality is that rejecting the Jewish people’s right to self-determination cannot be described as anything other than antisemitism, regardless of whether the person rejecting that right is an Arab like me or a leftist European.
21. “Europe supported Zionism because of guilt over the Holocaust”
The reverse is, in fact, true: Europe’s support for Zionism, although always weak, was stronger before the Holocaust than during and after the Holocaust.
The First Zionist Congress took place in 1897, 36 years before the Nazi party came to power in Germany. Britain’s Balfour Declaration supporting “the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people” occurred in 1917, two decades before the start of the Holocaust, but instead of helping Zionists, Britain imposed restricted immigration of Jews through the White Papers of 1922, 1930, and 1939, even while the Holocaust was taking place in Europe.
An embargo was imposed by the United States and supported by Europe on the sale of weapons to Israel and the Palestinian Arabs, starting in December 1947, soon after the United Nations announced a partition plan for Palestine. The embargo did not prevent Arabs from obtaining weapons, but it severely affected Israel which was able to survive only due to secret sales of armaments from Czechoslovakia, with the quiet approval of the Soviet Union. None of the countries that should have felt guilt for the Holocaust, most notably Germany, helped Israel get established or survive the Arab onslaught.
22. “Israel’s support for LGBT rights is a cover for its crimes”
Accusations of “pinkwashing” are in fact themselves a smokescreen for supporting Israel’s enemies who consistently use terrorism and hatred to ensure that the conflict continues.
As a left-wing Arab, I have always been disturbed by the fact that LGBT rights are practically non-existent in the Arab world. Instead of denouncing Israel’s support for LGBT rights, leftists should show their support for Arabs by demanding that Arab states emulate Israel.
23. “The BDS movement is a reasonable response to Israel”
The boycott-divestment-sanctions (BDS) movement is not an appropriate response to Israel because Israel’s actions are lawful and justified. The BDS movement – founded by Omar Barghouti who opposes the concept of a Jewish state – is, in fact, detrimental to peace, and it is driven by antisemitism, not by peaceful idealism. The BDS movement presents an image of respectability, but that is far from the truth. Since, its objectives, if achieved, would result in the killing of Jews and the return of the remaining Jews to the stateless and precarious status that they had before May 1948, the BDS movement represents an anti-Semitism at par with Hamas.
As an Arab who would like to see the Arab world become modern, liberal, democratic, and innovative, I would like to see exchanges between Israel and its neighbors, and lots of it, including trade, tourism, economic cooperation, cultural exchanges, and much more.
24. “Hatred of Israel is okay because anti-Zionism is not antisemitism”
Hatred of an entire people is never justified, and it is particularly wrong in the case of hatred of Israel because it is very clearly based on antisemitism. The related claim that Arabs cannot be antisemitic because they are Semites is a deflection. Encyclopedia Britannica: “The term anti-Semitism was coined in 1879 by the German agitator Wilhelm Marr to designate the anti-Jewish campaigns under way in central Europe at that time”. Anti-Zionism is in fact antisemitism, whether the person holding the belief is an Arab like me, a leftist like me, or neither.
25. “Israel is the cause of conflicts in the Middle East”
Israel’s enemies have accused Israel of initiating or encouraging conflicts to divert attention from itself. They have accused Israel for example of supporting ISIS. None of these accusations have ever been supported by credible evidence. The reality is that the Middle East has been involved in wars and conquests for many centuries. The Jews were several times massacred and expelled. Middle Eastern wars have a long history and were caused by several factors unrelated to Israel, including the two world wars, Shia/Sunni rivalry, Turkish imperialism, Roman imperialism, Persian imperialism, the Muslim empires, European imperialism, and tribalism.
Israel, on the other hand, has only had one objective, existing in peace, which it has so far not been allowed to do. As an Arab who would like to be able to visit my native country Lebanon without risk of being jailed because I communicate with Israelis, peace cannot come soon enough.
Not completely off topic: Marc Wadsworth,expelled from the Labour Party in connection with the anti-semitism row is an ex BBC employee and has worked with the BBC more recently on a race-based documentary.
ReplyDelete