Sunday 19 August 2018

"The voice of the Nazis. That’s the BBC"

Meanwhile, Andrew Marr issues a tweet...

...and receives over 600 replies from angry members of the FBPE community, most of them pretty much the same thing: that it's "faux outrage" on Mr. Marr's part as the BBC has been "complicit" or "instrumental" in the rise of the far-right in this country by promoting Nigel Farage (including those famous 32 appearances on Question Time) and by giving airtime to the likes of Tommy Robinson, Katie Hopkins, Gerard Batten, Raheem Kassam, Steve Bannon, Ezra Levant, Sebastian Gorka and Marine le Pen. The BBC has been "platforming fascists". 

Here's a flavour:

  • You do understand that the BBC has been complicit, right? Farage gets more airtime than the entire Lib Dem contingent in Parliament. Why is that?
  • So who will you invite on to the Marr show to ensure political balance on this? 1) Katie Hopkins 2) John Humphrys 3) Jacob Rees Mogg 4) Nigel Lawson 5) Yet another lobbyist from the Tax Avoiders Alliance #BBCswitchoff
  • Hope you recognise the role the BBC has played in uncritically amplifying the faux patriotic anti-immigrant culture in which these extreme views have thrived. The media is complicit in the lurch to the right, BBCQT being a case in point.
  • Enabled, encouraged and supported by Pro-Brexit supporters like YOU Marr.
  • Maybe if the BBC stopped platforming fascists?!
  • Says the person who defended interviewing & broadcasting Le Pen on Remembrance Sunday. Take responsibility for the part you play in what's happening Andrew Marr.
  • The irony is that it's been BBC journalists giving people like this a free pass for years, normalising this stuff through the likes of Hopkins, Farage and all the others you give publicity & easy rides to. You need to take a long, hard look in the mirror...
  • You gave an unchallenged platform to Marine Le Pen on Armistice Day. What did you think would be the outcome of that? The BBC news and current affairs department have promoted the far right for years.
  • I’m almost speechless at your hypocrisy. We wouldn’t be in this position if you and your organisation hadn’t been enabling and normalising the far right for the past few years. Own it.

Andrew Marr dipped a trepidatious toe into the responses:

...but probably now wishes he hadn't bothered.

Meanwhile, over on the wrong side of the Pennines, BBC Radio Leeds also issued a tweet:

"The voice of the Nazis. That’s the BBC" came one reply, and Alastair Campbell tweeted, "Sorry @BBCLeeds but really disagree with giving this woman a platform. Her views of Bradford will no doubt be racist and sweeping. Will she call it Bradistan?". 

Today a Labour MP leaped onward and tweeted the following to the BBC's head of live political programmes Rob Burley: 

The exchange between them has (so far) gone as follows:
Rob Burley: I don’t work for BBC Leeds.
Stephen Doughty MP: But you have oversight of  BBC News political programming right? Do you all just work in silos? Genuinely interested... would you invite her on one of the network political broadcasts?
Rob Burley: No. I run a set of programmes - they are listed on my bio. I can’t answer for regional political output.
Stephen Doughty MP: Ok - so you’re saying there’s no consistent editorial policy across political output on the BBC? Genuinely useful to know. Can I just ask again - would you invite her on to network political programmes you *are* responsible for?
Rob hasn't yet replied to that. I'm all intrigued to read what he'll say when he does.


Of course, by branding everyone from Nigel Farage to Tommy Robinson, from Katie Hopkins to Sebastian Gorka as "far-right" and then by tying them in with (a) old-time fascists and Nazis and (b) present-day far-right terrorists, these complainants are trying to make such people appear utterly beyond the pale. And they are also seeking to force the BBC refuse to give them - and their views - a platform, i.e. to censor them. 

Hmm, what if other free-speech-hating people started demanding that the BBC stop platforming the far-left (Paul Mason, Owen Jones, Ash Sarkar, etc) and even attempted to bully the BBC into not platforming political figures (even Labour Party leaders) with links to (a) old-time communists and (b) terrorist organisations? What then? 

Incidentally, the idea that Nigel Farage, despite his many Question Time appearances, was ever given an easy platform by the BBC is absurd and the reverse of the truth. Interviews with him over many years tended to fixate on accusations of racism in his party and BBC reports about his party had a pretty relentlessly negative focus, usually focusing on the similar questions. Let's not forget:
EVAN DAVIS: Did you see the Paddington Bear movie last year?
EVAN DAVIS: Terrific movie with a kind of rather sort of moving, in a sense, proclamation of the virtues of multiculturalism, which I know you hate, because he's a bear, and he's different and he feels very at home and is made to feel welcome here. Now would that be a 'metropolitan elite' movie that is kind of a tragedy...a travesty of British patriotism, of British values? 

1 comment:

  1. Andrew Marr illustrates the dangers of virtue signalling... :) One moment you're basking in the warm glow of your self-generated virtue, the next you are being hounded by a pack of rabid lefty hyenas intent on your destruction...Still I suppose that shows the BBC "get it about right". Andrew should just remind his persecutors that he spent most of his student days engaged in the thankless task of trying to flog extreme left wing Trotskyite/Maoist tracts to fellow students, not just spouting off on Twitter.


Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.