John Simpson: Welcome to Broadcasting House, part of the BBC's iconic headquarters here in central London for Unspun World, the programme where the BBC's experts around the globe give in-depth answers to the big questions of the day. This week...Has Brexit done long-term damage to Britain?Mark Easton: There's a sense in which we've not really been able to have sort of normal times to get stuff done. It's warped our politics and made it very difficult for our political leaders.John Simpson: It's six years since, in a result that surprised most people, the United Kingdom voted by a very narrow margin to leave the European Union. The campaign was marked by some hugely controversial claims, which have resonated ever since - the hundreds of millions we'd be able to pump into the NHS among them. It's still too early to work out the exact pluses and minuses of Brexit, but the lines are becoming clearer. I asked Mark Easton, the BBC's home editor, for his views. Has Brexit been a boon or a disaster?Mark Easton: It is a sort of fundamental difference of view which actually goes to people's heart, actually. Almost a sort of visceral feeling, I think. People feel very, very strongly about it - on both sides of the argument. And that, I think, has been quite troubling. There's a sense in which we've not really been able to have sort of normal times to get stuff done. So I think that's been another problem with the whole Brexit debate. It's warped our politics and made it very difficult for our political leaders to really sort of plough a furrow as they want to do. For many communities where we saw very significant Brexit votes, it was about connection to power. It was a sense that they'd been ignored. Many communities that I went to, they felt that change was happening to their communities - demographic change, free movement within the EU. Immigration generally meant that the communities they lived in were changing, the shops were changing.John Simpson: Also hearing people talking Polish or Romanian and so on in the streets.Mark Easton: Exactly. In particular, people, people would say that the thought of hearing a foreign language on the bus was disconcerting to them. It was different. It wasn't what they expected, and no-one had asked them about it. I think it would be fair to say that very few of those communities feel that they are any closer to power today than they were six years ago.John Simpson: So it hasn't achieved that?Mark Easton: Not yet, no. I mean, I guess the Government would argue that, you know, their whole levelling up agenda is partly about that - it's trying to reconnect communities that felt separate. I think that is definitely, you know, job not yet done, but really, really important, whether you whether you voted Leave or Remain, actually, that Britain does better in making sure that, you know, thousands of communities up and down this land don't feel - as they currently do - that they are exempted from the decisions that actually affect their daily lives.John Simpson: Have there been any successes for Brexit?Mark Easton: Undoubtedly free movement and the end of that. I think you can say, well, yeah, that's something - those people who wanted that to stop, it's happened. That was a promise made and a promise kept. They were also told that we would move to a points-based immigration system, to ensure that we only get the migrants that we want and we need. And, yes, we do have...John Simpson: Is that happening?Mark Easton: That has happened.John Simpson: And is it working?Mark Easton: Well, I think it's difficult because we do have shortages of labour in quite a number of areas, as we transition from what people would have said was our sort of - we'd become rather reliant on European workers and being able to turn on the immigration tap.John Simpson: Will Brexit destroy the United Kingdom?Mark Easton: Well, it certainly put the Union under very considerable strain. But what's interesting is that I think there is a pressure for more devolution, because I think there is a sense in which part of what Brexit was about was reconnecting people and they need power for that to happen. But what we've seen so far is not that - what we've seen, and perhaps a result of Covid - we've seen actually more power heading towards Number 10 and to Whitehall.John Simpson: Do you think at some stage there'll be another vote and we'll go back in?Mark Easton: I don't think that's going to happen for a very significant time. But it's interesting, I think, some of the economic realities which are coming into play and are going to become even more so if the forecasts for the UK economy prove to be correct, where people are going to say, well, hold on, are we really cutting off our nose to spite our face? And we need to have some kind of sensible arrangement with our nearest trading partners to make sure that we don't miss out on all those trading opportunities. Making it more difficult for people to trade with countries just over the Channel is not very sensible when your economy is facing so many other huge challenges.
Thursday, 23 June 2022
“This week...Has Brexit done long-term damage to Britain?”
Monday, 20 June 2022
This year it's 'definite' though...
Buried in Manchester
- Oldham child sex exploitation report is extraordinary: “Offender A worked for Oldham Council between 1998 and 2006. He was employed as a welfare rights officer in the welfare rights unit of the council seconded to the Oldham Pakistani Community centre”.
- “In May 2012 he was found guilty of two rapes, aiding and abetting rape, sexual assault and trafficking for the purposes of sexual exploitation […] offender A lived in Oldham and was a member of the Oldham Labour Party”.
- And: “At the end of Sept 2008, the Probation Service notified Oldham Council that offender A had been charged with sexual assault. No action was taken by Oldham Cl to undertake a safeguarding assessment of Off A following this information or to liaise with colleagues in GM Police.”
- “Furthermore, it was known by the police that offender A was a council employee and insufficient enquiries were made into whether his role gave him access to vulnerable adults and children.”
- “… throughout this period, legitimate concerns on the part of both the council & the police that high-profile convictions of predominantly Pakistani offenders across the country could be capitalised on by a far-right agenda & lead to the victimisation of the Pakistani community”.
- Jim McMahon, Labour’s Shadow Defra Secretary, who was leader of Oldham Council from 2011 to 2016, clearly has some very difficult questions to answer.
The report pointed out that while most arrests for child sex offences by GMP in the period between September 2009 and July 2010 then identified the alleged offenders as being Asian, they were likely to have generally related to British men of Pakistani or Bangladeshi heritage.
What is astonishing here is that the earliest versions of the BBC report show the BBC still doing precisely that, just as they always used to do - thus showing just the kind of mindset and massaging of language the inquiry criticised:
The independent inquiry was set up after allegations circulated on social media that Oldham Council was covering up what it knew about Asian grooming gangs in the town.
Then suddenly the BBC removed the word 'Asian' [click to enlarge]:
She went to Oldham police station to report being raped by an Asian man in October 2006 and was told to come back when she was "not drunk".
She went to Oldham police station to report being sexually assaulted in October 2006 and was told to come back when she was "not drunk".
Goodall news
Departing from the BBC means that now Goodall is, at last, free to share his political views that have been so well-concealed to date.
The top comment at Guido Fawkes hit the spot too:
I for one will be curious to learn what Lewis's real views are now that he will be no longer having to work under BBC impartiality rules.
Maybe LBC should add another B to their name and become LBBC?
Macron's 'win'
Sunday, 19 June 2022
To infinity and...er...right down the rating plughole
Marvel reveals Muslim comic-book superhero, Kamala Khan07/11/2013Ms Marvel: Muslim superhero film 'in the works', Marvel says - BBC …14/05/2018Ms Marvel: Trailblazing Muslim superhero goes gaming01/07/2020Marvel has cast its first onscreen Muslim superhero!01/10/2020Ms Marvel on TV: A 'bold move for Marvel to diversify their characters'02/10/2020Ms. Marvel: First trailer revealed - what do we know16/03/2022Ms Marvel: We meet the MCU's first Muslim superhero!06/06/2022Why Marvel has struck gold with Muslim superhero Ms Marvel07/06/2022Ms Marvel: Critics praise Disney's 'joyful' first Muslim superhero story09/06/2022
Ms Marvel: 'I felt I belonged on set'
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/newsbeat-61828735
19/06/2022
And this is where reality rides in on a horse of bold colours...
Moving away from the BBC's cheerleading on Newsround and Newsbeat and Twitter and the BBC website to the real world of what audiences actually want to watch, it's clear that the viewing public aren't anywhere near so enthusiastic.
To put it mildly.
The programme has massively flopped in the ratings so far, scoring a new low for any MCU-branded programme by a vast margin.
So, presumably being seen to be unwanted and woke, Ms Marvel has 'gone broke' and absolutely bombed.
The series might be fun and delightful - as per the friendly critics and the BBC - but the public clearly aren't inclined to watch it, for whatever reasons.
My guess then is that the BBC will now keep quiet about Ms Marvel flopping with the public...at least until Twitter/their US media allies starts blaming the audience's disinclination to watch it on racism. Then the Beeb is bound to lurch back into action.
Of one mind
Austin Williams, director of Future Cities: First ten minutes of The World This Weekend is an uncritical stage for an environmental lobbyist.Repeat ad nauseum.Does anyone at the BBC worry about journalistic standards and open enquiry? Clearly Jonny Dymond doesn't, but anyone?
Tim Montgomerie, pundit: Just listened to R4’s World This Weekend and struck again at the self-loathing running through BBC News. Yes, The West has polluted too much, but that same industrialisation road has given the whole world the medicine, tech, wealth etc that makes solutions and progress possible.
It really feels like the richer world has decided to abandon those who are facing devastation to deal with thing on their own.
The world's economy is very dislocated, on the back of Covid, on the back of an inflation crisis, and so can we continue to negotiate the things that have to happen from a climate perspective? That's the big test. Can we walk and chew gum at the same time?
But Bonn broke up without the agreement the countries most vulnerable to climate change had hoped for, for assistance from the rich world - which has, after all, fed the fires of global warming - in dealing with the rising seas, floods and droughts that now batter those most vulnerable countries ever more regularly and fiercely.
How big a deal is it? I mean, is it a more important deal, to be brutal about it, that poor countries get shafted? - which is probably something we've known about for decades now.
The BBC certainly knows how to hector. Why can't it just report the news and keep its opinions to itself?
Saturday, 18 June 2022
Comparing GB News with Newsnight
'...But critics say that the plan treats those fleeing persecution as criminals...Well, they are, aren't they? They crossed the Channel illegally. Sorry, did I say that out loud?
BBC Distrust
Is the c-word highly controversial?
“Another low”
Fact-checking the BBC [2]
Fact-checking the BBC
The grass fire on the mountain used in the clip was caused by arson. The BBC even reported this themselves.https://t.co/zX2S3MjJsK
— Jamie Jenkins (@statsjamie) June 17, 2022
Where are the BBC's own fact-checkers?
Red ink
The BBC has evidently been massaging the message:
Friday, 17 June 2022
The BBC and Julian Assange
This decision is the most important stage so far in Mr Assange's long legal battle.Judges in London have already ruled that the US's request was lawful and that the American authorities would care for him properly in prison.Now, the home secretary has carried out her role in the complicated legal process by signing off the US request.Her officials said she was legally bound to do so because Mr Assange does not face the death penalty - nor does his case fall into the other narrow range of categories for her to refuse to approve the transfer.In practice, this means there is nothing to stop Washington sending a jet to pick up Mr Assange - unless he can win on appeal.If his lawyers cannot get a hearing back before judges in London, he could petition the European Court of Human Rights.Ten years ago it ruled extradition to the US would not breach human rights - but expect the Wikileaks founder to try fresh arguments not heard back then.
Journalists in Britain and elsewhere will be very worried by the decision to extradite Julian Assange to the US — both for his own well-being & for the precedent it creates for journalism worldwide.
A tweet from ex-BBC/Newsnight whistleblower Meirion Jones tonight, meanwhile, casts a clarifying light on how things were a decade or so ago, when views of Julian Assange were rather different:
All media that were in on Wikileaks should be calling for Assange extradition to be stopped. That includes BBC - I know because I was courier between David Leigh's Kings Place bunker & Beeb World Affairs Unit for diplo leaks ahead of release 29/10/10.
Butterflies
Mary Harrington: This is a scandal. The BBC is meant to be politically neutral, not hiring ideologues to catechise their HR teams on how to ensure all staff enforce only one one side of perhaps the most controversial and divisive political issue out there.The fascinating complication in this latest story of trans activism sweeping the BBC is that it was a BBC programme that broke it, with Stephen Nolan continuing his charge against trans extremism at the BBC.
“Diversity? You're having a laugh!”
Yes - I'm on Sky Arts! The only arts channel left in Britain, now that the BBC is replacing BBC4 with the kiddy channel - BBC3. Think about that folks. ONE ARTS CHANNEL LEFT IN BRITAIN. Compare it to cooking, murder, property, costume drama etc. Diversity? You're having a laugh!
Tuesday, 14 June 2022
Sir Lenny leads the news
privilege
[ˈprɪvɪlɪdʒ]
NOUN
a special right, advantage, or immunity granted or available only to a particular person or group
In a country that's 86% white, what does he expect? Just because we see a 50-50 mix on BBC & ITV entertainment and drama programmes and a majority of black people in adverts, does it mean it truly reflects the demographics of our society?
Musical tastes aren't racism.
Taking ambiguity to new levels
Monday, 13 June 2022
A familiar tale
Decline and Fall
Emily Kate: In the space of about 25 years, R4 has gone from a radio station full of sparkling, brilliant people you'd feel incredibly privileged to meet, to a radio station full of the most boring people at the most boring gathering you have ever been to in your life. I know I'm always tweeting about how awful R4 is now, but I just cannot get over what has happened to it. I will never stop being shocked at its total collapse, its descent from the dizzying heights of an enlightened elite broadcaster to dreary third-rate university podcast.
Sunday, 12 June 2022
Gordon Brown, the Just Steward
Storm Fagan, BBC curator
We have a really ethical approach to machine learning, where we are looking at removing any bias from the algorithm.
It means we are seeing really good quality return on results for users. We can balance national versus local as well because you are not reinforcing an echo chamber. You are showing them a more curated view of BBC content.
That is quite different from other products where they are driving clicks, so they are trying to show you more of the same thing.
"Encouraging a wide range of content", or in other words shoving woke down your throat.
Given Storm's Twitter bio, with its pronouns and rainbow '/pride' emoji, that commenter might be onto something.
According to LinkedIn, she/her went to Combe Bank School, a girls-only private school in Kent where she was deputy head girl.
What really caught my attention though was her list of 'Influencers' on she/her LinkedIn page. Five people are listed, including the Labour Mayor of London Sadiq Khan.
Personally-speaking, I'd have removed that when joining the BBC if I'd have been her. It's a bit rum for a BBC boss to keep Sadiq as an 'Influencer' after joining the BBC.
A Look Back
One of Britain's most acclaimed artists, the sculptor Sir Antony Gormley, who created The Angel of the North, is to become a German citizen. Sir Antony said he was giving up his British passport because of the UK's decision leave the European Union. He described the move as "embarrassing" and says he has plans for new sculptures that reflect this view.
BBC One, 4 June 2022, 10.30pmWe reported that the acclaimed British sculptor Sir Antony Gormley is to become a German citizen. We said he was giving up his British passport because of the UK’s decision to leave the European Union and that he had described the move as embarrassing and had plans for new sculptures that would reflect his view.In fact Sir Antony Gormley is not giving up his British nationality and has asked us to make clear the circumstances behind his application for a German passport.Sir Antony holds dual nationality as a result of having a German mother and has decided to apply for a German passport, which he will hold alongside his British one.In a statement he says he remains a proud British citizen and is grateful for the extraordinary support he has received from so many people and institutions across the UK but he is also keen to retain his links with and continue to show his work in Europe.We apologise for the mistake.07/06/2022
How did this happen? As far as I can see, the BBC simply picked the story up from their Sunday house journal The Observer and misread it.
Nowhere in the Observer article did Sir Antony say he was giving up his British passport [and I've checked the Wayback Machine to see if the Observer did say it but then changed it].
So were the BBC 'projecting', seeing what they wanted to see in the story rather than what it actually said?
It certainly looks like it.
II
Meanwhile, following a number of apologies for 'errors' made by the BBC's climate editor Justin Rowlatt - who's far clumsier than the departing Roger Harrabin - there's a new report out by Paul Homewood detailing a dozen corrections/apologies the BBC's had to make in recent years for false claims.
Justin, who first rose to fame as Newsnight's 'Ethical Man', is now up to three strikes [BBC ECU rulings against him], though naturally he's not 'out' at the BBC:
In 2021 he falsely claimed that the offshore wind industry was now 'virtually subsidy free'.
In 2022 he falsely claimed that the death toll from climate change is rising.
In 2022 he falsely claimed that the recent drought in Madagascar was 'the world's first climate-induced famine'.
I was particularly intrigued by the passages about the BBC's complaints process, including this concerning the false claim about the death toll rising:
A complaint to the BBC was fobbed off with the risible excuse that Panorama was referring to the cumulative death toll, which will obviously rise every year.
I wish I could say that was 'a nice try' by the BBC, but it's so disingenuous as to be anything but.
As the press release accompanying the report notes, the BBC has a team of reality checkers, including a 'Climate Misinformation' section.
Yet none of these teams of fact checkers noticed or addressed the long list of false news stories that were only corrected by the BBC after lengthy and protracted complaint procedures.
Those BBC reality checkers are very selective in the 'facts' they choose to 'check'.
III
Worst of all was the BBC's editing of an online report to change a rape victim's words - replacing 'he' and 'him' with 'they' and 'them' in order not to offend the trans person accused of raping the woman - a truly staggering editorial intervention.
And why beholdest thou the mote that is in thy brother's eye, but considerest not the beam that is in thine own eye?
Correction 30 May: An earlier version of this piece stated there had been one mass shooting in the UK following Dunblane. There have been two, based on the definition widely used in the US of four or more deaths.
...the same spinal integrity as a sea anemone
Everyone with spots and hormonal issues ran around waving their pierced arms in the air and gnashing their tattooed teeth, saying that this colonial and racist attitude is exactly what’s wrong with privileged white men today.
.,,despite the moral of Len's story surely being that Len had learned and changed:
So Len doesn’t need to be criticised for saying how things used to be. He needs to be praised for having the wit and the strength of character to change his way.
...Because it has the same spinal integrity as a sea anemone, the BBC instructed Clare Balding to issue an on-air apology for the “offence”.
That's a particularly fine turn of phrase.
“A horribly preachy [BBC] drama”
This BBC film about a child dealing with racism in 1980s Birmingham promises real-world lessons but delivers saccharine platitudes.
Rachel Cooke further chargrills it thusly:
Horribly preachy and overly schematic, this film feels more like one made for children than for adults – and sure enough, every single actor in it turns in the kind of ostentatiously heart-warming performance that suggests they’re present as much as a matter of duty as because they relish their role; that they have, in fact, signed up to teach an important lesson rather than to perform a subtle, complex drama.
You may not be surprised to learn that Sir Lenny Henry is its executive producer.
Meanwhile, it seems that BBC comedy is no laughing matter either.
Romesh Ranganathan’s new BBC One show Avoidance doesn't appear to be exercising too many people's chuckle muscles. The Daily Telegraph's Marianka Swain charitably says it has “almost no redeeming features”. Naturally, I've not seen it, but the top-rated comment at the Telegraph describes it like this.
Let's just get this right...an Asian bloke in a mixed-race marriage runs to his sister who is in a lesbian mixed race marriage. Yup! 5 out of 5 for reflecting normal life on the BBC.
The Strange Case of 'The BBC-Deprived'
Saturday, 11 June 2022
In Poor Nick
Nick Robinson of the BBC devotes his considerable energies to removing Boris. Presumably with this confirmation bias, Robinson kept repeating on Today on Tuesday that Johnson’s vote was ‘worse than Margaret Thatcher’s in 1990’. This was an odd thing to say, partly because they were different types of vote (his a no-confidence one, hers a leadership election), but mainly because it is untrue. In 1990, Mrs Thatcher received 204 votes from an electorate of 372. In 2022, Boris Johnson received 211 votes from an electorate of 359. I am no statistician, but I make that more votes, both proportionally and absolutely, for him than for her. In the same programme, the political editor, Chris Mason repeated LBJ’s dictum that the first requirement in politics is to be able to count. He politely did not point out that his illustrious predecessor in the job seems to lack that skill.
Here are Nick Robinson's remarks from that 7 June edition of Today:
- 6:12 - On one measure the Prime Minister got fewer votes the Margaret Thatcher when she was challenged back in 1990.
- 7:09 - His critics, you won't be surprised to hear, see it somewhat differently, pointing out that Boris Johnson did less well than Theresa May, John Major, even Margaret Thatcher, when they faced challenges from their MPs.
- 7:42 - So history will not repeat itself? Boris Johnson will not have to go, in your view, simply because he did worse than Margaret Thatcher?
- 7:47 - I've just been speaking to one of the veterans of the Margaret Thatcher leadership contest. Boris Johnson did worse than Margaret Thatcher. But they say, doesn't matter.
All Biased on the Easton Front
BBC news this morning with a report about boat migrants. Every clip they showed was with young children being carried into the UK. Who are they kidding? Everyone can see the boats being unloaded with men only. Women and children are few and far between....
That's a familiar complaint.