The BBC’s Sketchy Obituary of Richard Rogers, Architect

Guest Post by Arthur T

It’s easier to copy the two contrasting obituaries of Richard Rogers and Zaha Hadid (2016), than to relay second-hand the reasons, biases and omissions of the less respectful of the two - that of Lord Rogers of Riverside. However, a comparison of the length and detail of the two is telling. Rogers’ 249 words and two illustrations, Hadid’s 839 words and 5 images - Rogers shown unsmiling against a black background, Hadid shown relaxed against a sunny sky. ‘Dame’ in Hadid’s, but no ‘Lord’ in Rogers’. There’s also a section in Hadid’s from the then BBC Arts Correspondent, Will Gompertz, but no similar write-up for Rogers. Rogers’ article is given little prominence on the BBC News website homepage. I guess it won’t be long before it disappears altogether.

Richard Rogers: Millennium Dome architect dies aged 88

Millennium Dome architect Richard Rogers has died at the age of 88.

A spokesman said he had "passed away quietly" on Saturday evening.

He first came to prominence with his radical designs for the Pompidou Centre in Paris and the Lloyd's of London building.

Lord Rogers was regarded as one of the world's most successful and influential architects, and he won most of his industry's major honours. He was knighted in 1991.

Born in 1933 to an Anglo-Italian family in Florence, he trained at the Architectural Association School of Architecture in London before graduating with a master's from Yale.

In the 1970s and 1980s, he became widely known for two buildings that were controversial at the time for putting amenities like lifts and air conditioning ducts on the outside -the Pompidou in Paris and the Lloyds building in London.

His other creations included the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, the Welsh Assembly in Cardiff, Terminal 5 at Heathrow Airport and Terminal 4 of Madrid's Barajas Airport.

He also built 3 World Trade Center in New York, an 80-storey skyscraper on the site of the former Twin Towers.

His critics over the years included Prince Charles, who spoke about his dislike of Lord Rogers' designs on several occasions…..

Architect Dame Zaha Hadid dies after heart attack

Will Gompertz looks back at the life of "trailblazer" Dame Zaha Hadid

Architect Dame Zaha Hadid, whose designs include the London Olympic Aquatic Centre, has died aged 65.

Iraqi-born, this year she was the first woman to receive the Royal Institute of British Architects (Riba) Gold Medal in recognition of her work.

She died following a heart attack on Thursday in a Miami hospital, where she was being treated for bronchitis.

Her designs have been commissioned around the world, including Hong Kong, Germany and Azerbaijan.

• Dame Zaha Hadid's award-winning designs

Collecting her Gold Medal in February, Dame Zaha said she was proud to have been the first woman to win in her own right.

"We now see more established female architects all the time," she said.

"That doesn't mean it's easy. Sometimes the challenges are immense. There has been tremendous change over recent years and we will continue this progress."

Dame Zaha's other creations include the Serpentine Sackler Gallery in London, the Riverside Museum at Glasgow's Museum of Transport, and Guangzhou Opera House in China.

She twice won the Riba Stirling Prize, the UK's most prestigious architecture award. In 2010 she won for the Maxxi Museum in Rome, winning again in 2011 for the Evelyn Grace Academy in Brixton.

Born in Baghad, she studied maths at the American University of Beirut - where she later designed a building on campus which was completed in 2014 - before embarking on her career at the Architectural Association in London.

In 1979 she set up her own company - Zaha Hadid Architects.

Her first major commission to be constructed was the Vitra Fire Station in Weil am Rhein in Germany.

The striking London Acquatics Centre in Stratford, which resembles a wave, features two 50-metre pools and a diving pool. After being used for the Olympics and Paralympics it was opened to the public in 2014.

"I love the London Aquatics Centre because it's near where I live," Dame Zaha said at the time.

London Mayor Boris Johnson wrote on Twitter: "So sad to hear of death of Zaha Hadid, she was an inspiration and her legacy lives on in wonderful buildings in Stratford and around the world."

She designed one of the stadiums that will take centre stage at the Qatar World Cup in 2022.

Last year, however, the Japanese government scrapped plans to build the futuristic-looking stadium she designed for the 2020 Olympics in Tokyo, opting instead for a scaled-down, less costly design.

Riba president Jane Duncan said: "This is absolutely terrible news. Dame Zaha Hadid was an inspirational woman, and the kind of architect one can only dream of being.

"Visionary and highly experimental, her legacy despite her young age, is formidable. She leaves behind a body of work from buildings to furniture, footwear and cars, that delight and astound people all around the world. The world of architecture has lost a star today."

Analysis: Will Gompertz, arts editor

Dame Zaha Hadid was an extraordinary human being. She was not only one of Britain's greatest architects, but one of the world's great architects of the 21st Century and late 20th Century.

She was most famous in the UK for the Aquatic Centre for the 2012 Olympic Games and for Maggie's Centres in Scotland.

She won the Stirling Prize for architecture twice and was the first woman to win the Pritzker Prize for architecture - Dame Zaha was an extraordinary woman considering where she came from and what she made of her career.

It was very much a man's world but she was determined to shape it and bend into the way she saw it, into Zaha Hadid's world.

Her architecture was modern and futuristic with very noticeable sensuous lines, she brought a femininity to Modernism.

Dame Zaha always had a problem in Britain to be taken as seriously as she should have been.

People tried to knock her quite a lot and she didn't get the commissions she thought she should.

She was very frustrated by that especially as she traded very well overseas. I don't know what the reason for that is but it wasn't because she wasn't a great architect.

Her legacy is to prove what can be done; that you can be a Baghdad-born British citizen who can cut through all the red tape, all the machismo, all the macho behaviour and become an internationally-respected architect who creates buildings which will stand the test of time.

And Dame Zaha will be seen as a leading light for any architect, especially female architects who have come from abroad and are living in Britain, to show that they can succeed in this country even through all the brickbats you receive along the way.

Why the difference? There’s no ‘more to follow’. Rogers was of Jewish descent, Zahid of Muslim descent. Does the anti-Semitic bias routinely displayed by the BBC extend to this level? I would estimate that Rogers’ output of completed works exceeds that of Zahid’ by a factor of fifty or so. Lord Rogers is one of the most important and influential architects of the 20th C. His contribution cannot be cancelled in this way.