Thursday 15 January 2015


I have to mention this because it’s about the BBC and a ridiculous submission to a ridiculous demand, so inappropriate in the light of recent events. This is an excerpt from Douglas Murray’s article in the Spectator.

The night after the Charlie Hebdo atrocities I was pre-recording a Radio 4 programme. My fellow discussant was a very nice Muslim man who works to ‘de-radicalise’ extremists. We agreed on nearly everything. But at some point he said that one reason Muslims shouldn’t react to such cartoons is that Mohammed never objected to critics.
 There may be some positive things to be said about Mohammed, but I thought this was pushing things too far and mentioned just one occasion when Mohammed didn’t welcome a critic. Asma bint Marwan was a female poetess who mocked the ‘Prophet’ and who, as a result, Mohammed had killed. It is in the texts. It is not a problem for me. But I can understand why it is a problem for decent Muslims. The moment I said this, my Muslim colleague went berserk. How dare I say this? I replied that it was in the Hadith and had a respectable chain of transmission (an important debate). He said it was a fabrication which he would not allow to stand. The upshot was that he refused to continue unless all mention of this was wiped from the recording. The BBC team agreed and I was left trying to find another way to express the same point. The broadcast had this ‘offensive’ fact left out.

This seems to be the meme du jour. That the individual described by the BBC as ‘the prophet Mohammed’ (to distinguish him from any other Mohammed/Mohammad, and not to imply that he’s everyone’s prophet)  - what was I saying - oh yes, the meme du jour is that the Muslim prophet whose image must not be reproduced, is forgiving and would rise above criticism with a smile. Well, maybe not with a smile.
Mehdi Hasan said it on Question Time, and later on This Week the Muslim ‘comedienne’ Shazia Mirza said it again. What is going on here? Has there been a memo from Allah?


  1. Douglas Murray remains one of the best hopes we`ve got.
    He cries in the wilderness of university campuses and the BBC...but a lot of us respect him greatly...and we follow in our ways.
    A worthy successor to Melanie, Mr Hitchens and Booker...tends to make mince of whoever is up against him, think he hammered Ming Campbell in a recent Newsnight...and we saw what a venal vacuous windbag and creep this Mr Nice actually turns out to be.
    Ta Douglas!

    1. Douglas is better than Melanie any day.


Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.