From Paul Adams to Paul Wood...
The BBC's Paul Wood has a piece on the Mediterranean immigrant crisis in The Spectator. His language tells us a fair amount about where he's coming from.
It begins:
A young woman in a headscarf stumbled over some rocks and onto the beach. She stood there, rigid, stunned, then burst into tears. A grandmotherly German tourist hugged her. ‘It’s over now, you’re safe,’ she said. ‘You’re in Europe.’
I don't think, however, that we're meant to approve of the lady with the Essex accent though, given the way Paul Wood mocks her way of speaking (and her hair):
On Lesbos, the boats’ arrival is a tourist attraction, people gathering on the road above the beach to watch. ‘Just fack off, you dirty people, roo-nin’ our ’oliday,’ shouted a peroxide blonde woman with an Essex accent as a group of migrants struggled over the lip of the hill onto the road.
This is reporting that appears to adhere to Lyse Doucet's view of BBC reporting:
I do believe absolutely that we have to show compassion. Otherwise we would...I mean you'd have to have a heart of stone not to be moved by what is happening in the wars of our time.
There was certainly plenty of compassion...and anger in Paul Wood's Spectator piece.
Anita Anand was at it as well - predetermining that any solution to the crisis had to show compassion to the migrants. I think we should show compassion...but it's not for reporters and presenters to demand compassion.
ReplyDelete